U.S. government safety officials urged Tuesday that aircraft owners be required to retrofit small planes with shoulder-lap seat belts but stopped short of calling for the installation of air bags.
A three-year study of small plane accidents released by the National Transportation Safety Board found several cases in which air bags prevented serious injuries or fatalities. But investigators said that since only about 7,000 planes have air bags, there haven’t been enough accidents to judge whether they should be required on all planes.
Though air bags have been mandated in automobiles for more than a decade, the aviation industry has no such requirement for small aircraft.
“The good news is that over 30 manufacturers have stepped up to the plate and offer air bags as standard or optional equipment,” NTSB chairman Deborah Hersman said.
One reason the board is looking at air bags for general aviation planes is that the accident rate for such planes is more than five times greater than small commuter airlines or air taxis, Hersman said.
There are more than 200,000 general aviation aircraft, mostly small, single-engine planes, NTSB officials said. The average age of the planes is about 40-years-old, officials said.
A second study, also released by NTSB on Tuesday, concluded that fatalities and serious injuries are 50 percent more likely to occur in accidents where pilots and passengers are wearing lap-only belts, rather than shoulder-lap belts. The study looked at 37,000 accidents involving single-engine planes between 1983 and 2008.
The board estimated that 13 to 26 percent of small planes don’t have shoulder belts. The cost of adding shoulder belts ranges from about $150 to $300 per seat, officials said.
NTSB first recommended that older planes be retrofitted with shoulder belts in 1977. The Federal Aviation Administration has required shoulder seat belts for all seats on newly manufactured planes since 1986, but doesn’t require older planes be retrofitted, board officials said.
The board can make only nonbinding recommendations.
FAA first approved air bags for use in small planes in 2003. Some aircraft manufacturers, including Cessna and Cirrus, voluntarily began including them as standard equipment on new planes beginning in 2005.
AmSafe Inc. of Phoenix, the only U.S. maker of air bags for planes, has documented 20 cases in the last several years in which its air bags were important to the survival of general aviation pilots and passengers, Joseph Smith, an AmSafe manager, said in an interview.
There were 474 people killed in 1,474 general aviation accidents in 2009, the latest year for which NTSB figures are available. While accident rate for commercial airlines has dropped significantly in the last decade, the general aviation rate in the period has remained largely unchanged.
AmSafe air bags are integrated into the shoulder harness or lap portion of airplane seat belts.
AmSafe does not make air bags for helicopters, but there is no reason it should not be possible, Smith said.
